Hello Butlerblock, I apologize that this player report took so long. I have looked into this situation to verify all the information given, and this conversation has sparked discussion about our metagaming rules amongst staff members. We agree with your assessment that this action constitutes metagaming, but as we feel it is not clearly outlined in the rules, it does not seem just to punish the culpable player. With that said, this incident has been logged and is being used to reapproach our metagaming rules, and will factor into our amendment of the rules in the future. This appeal is approved , however no action is being taken against the player