Right, so trying to get back to basics instead of own-zoning (and also because I have a busy day so the usual neurotic act of pulling Discord and Forum messages to that someone’s a hypocrite or dishonest isn’t viable), I think that there’s certainly a lot of arguing for the continued use of ‘Jamaicans’ that just . . . doesn’t track.
They Did It In The Movies:
Compared to the more recent and the more successful entries into the franchise: Predator 2 is the lowest-grossing, and second-lowest rated. It’s incredibly easy to tell that it is nobody’s favorite predator movie, with the only long-lasting effects it’s had being as the movie that added some of the more fun weapons like the combistick and smart disk, and for the greater lore establishments such as the Xenomorph skull in the background of the same scene where we discover the Predators are a larger society instead of lone wolves, and have been hunting for a while.
The nickname didn’t come up in the second movie. The context is that the Police and other gangs were dealing with a Jamaican gang, many of which had dreadlocks, so it makes sense that they could mistake a the Predator one of the gang me- except at no point did anybody see the Predator and think they looked like the gang members. While following-up on crimes the Jamaican Voodoo Posse committed which included hanging people upside down and cutting them open, they immediately rule-out the Jamaicans and Latin gangs because they logically fit. From here the person who saw the Predator kill the Jamaicans calls them ‘El Diablo’, our detective talks to the Jamaican gang boss about this third-entity and King Willie calls him a “spirit from the other side” and a demon, and they even have a full scene where a bunch of glowies take the protagonist into a van and directly show him that they know what the Predator is, tied him to the first movies, explained that they know how his weapons work and can cloak with stealth technology they want, know that he’s an alien.
To summarize a wall: Predator 2 is a post-first contact scenario where the US Government recognizes the Predators and their abilities, tied them to multiple other sightings, desire their technology, and even the fucking LAPD couldn’t racially profile the guy with dreadlocks as Jamaican while they were directly fighting a Jamaican gang IN THE LEAD-UP TO THE RODNEY KING RIOTS.
Oh they were also allowed to indiscriminately kill anybody holding a gun, while cloaked, regardless of whether or not anybody fired those weapons, pointed them at the Predator, or even if they could have potentially seen them: as observed when he busted through the roof of a train to kill a bunch of civilians defending themselves from gang members before anybody fired once. We’re not giving that a pass for lore-accuracy or roleplay, and nobody’s fighting for the right to call Runners “Dragons” or “Beasts” as a beloved reference to the worst-rated, third-worst-performing Alien movie.
Source: I watched the movie.
It’s not a secret that this server has had an issue with toxic in the past: There vocal outrage a few days ago with the r-slur ban, and some years back for the n-word, then variations on the n-word, and then variations on those.
That’s where this asinine double-standard comes in: Whose voice matters? “Your voices on this don’t matter, because you’re white, but we get to use this word because we (white) don’t see it as racist, and because some people who have Jamaican ancestry say it’s fine” is already obnoxious, especially on top of the fact that of course there aren’t that many Black, Queer, Female, Jamaican, or other minority groups to speak against this shit. SS13 has a basis in /TG/ - a 4chan board - hosting large communities, and the largest influx of players the game saw in potentially its whole lifespan coming from a Danish guy who larps as an African warlord and ends every video with an antisemitic Patreon plug: of course a lot of those groups will see that alone and be able to tell this space wouldn’t want them. Then they come in, see people fighting over their God-given right to say slurs on the internet, only for a bunch of guys playing characters whiter than Starship Troopers get off a ship ready to go and “kill some Jamaicans” while someone doing an Engrish accent orders them to do a kamikaze attack, and have that reinforced.
Hell, one of my very first experiences in SS13 was saving the station from a wizard by accident, only for someone to call my character a N-word but starts with L because I was playing a Lizardman
and lynching me. I’m certain they could have come-up with an in-character justification or asked their pet skink if that was okay, doesn’t change the results.
If you do want to look to a person of color’s advice or comfort for once, the only ones in this community are the people who made it through the filter that caught everyone else.
The space was made unwelcoming towards marginalized groups, and that’s who “exclusivity” is for: not some blue-haired liberal arts majors who are able to enter these spaces without immediate harassment based on their religion, culture, or the color of their skin. The only time Jamaicans are brought-up being in context of whether or not it’s valid to use that name on some pixelated aliens isn’t a good look.
TL;DR: ‘Jamaicans’ isn’t accurate to any of the movies, the movies exist post-first-contact where we can call them “Predators” and “Aliens” just fine as they’ve been deemed multiple times on-screen while knowing what their tools are like. Pretending to care about PoC voices means nothing when a community hostile to them was fostered and rejected any PoC who were bothered years ago, meaning it becomes an argument of whether or not to hold onto the same behaviors that made the community barely hospitable to marginalized identities in the first place.
Patrice. Nerd Emoji.