Mistermoon - Staff Report: Enforcement Action Taken - Vending Machine

Mistermoon - Staff Report: Enforcement Action Taken - Vending Machine

What’s your BYOND key:

Mistermoon

Round ID:

29895

Your character name:

John JC Crimson

Their BYOND key:

Vending Machine

What are you reporting?:

Enforcement Action Taken

Description of the incident:

MPs had shot at me prior in the round during a jailbreak induced by Svato Plink, I was able to flee in which he started using a disabler once his revolver ran out of ammo in which I was hit once, no violent acts were committed by me or Plink before we were shot at and no attempts of non lethal detainment had been made, this typically means lethals have been authorised and the suspect is being treated as a hostile entity, I had contacted admins through Ahelp prior to make sure that it was still the case that under these circumstances you may also treat the MPs hostile considering it would be silly that an MP would be allowed to walk up to you with a shotgun and PB you with you not being allowed to do anything lest you want to face admin intervention.

Although I hadn’t been directly hit as the MP shooting had missed all shots, I described the incident in ahelp to make sure I was free to go through with this action, the moderator Vending Machine agreed I was allowed to shoot back at them, I believed the fact that I was using ahelp was more than enough notice to imply the engagement was over in which they agreed with me initially, however it was clear afterwards they thought I was getting actively shot at the time of the ahelp, he did investigate further, commenting on all shots being missed, yet never clarifying that escalation rules would still be treated as if I were a friendly force.

I met up with the one that had freed me earlier which was Svato Plink, who was also shot at by the MP that initially shot at me who (although not very valuable) could testify saying that lethals were shot at us, in which we agreed to go and try to free more people considering a number of important roles in the round had been arrested, this led to an engagement with brig being breached and some MPs dead with one decapped, this was a contentious point by Vending Machine stating I had intentionally decapped him even though it happened as part of a burst fire spray and so would have been difficult to avoid in the situation.

Considering once brig was breached the MPs had guns drawn anyway, it simply confirmed that the kill on sight order was being upheld in at least some regard so I proceeded with what I thought had been cleared by Vending Machine.

A similar situation happened a while ago in which a dialogue between forest and I happened in which he had agreed that once you are considered a hostile force by the MPs outside of escalation, you may retaliate the same assuming the actions have motive (self defence etc.) and as long as bystanders dont wind up victims

In whole I don’t believe he was acting maliciously, it is a delicate situation that had confusion on both sides and the logs can’t tell the whole story so if you were witness it would greatly help if you add your input.

Evidence:

— Initial ahelp messages —

PM to-Admins: MPs shot at me with lethals, can i fight back now, just checking to make sure

– Administrator private message –
Admin PM from-Vending Machine: if they’re using lethals, you can too. non-lethal mp tools count as fists or general melee
Click on the administrator’s name to reply.

— Decap happening not intentionally during a firefight —

John ‘JC’ Crimson has been hit in the chest by the M44 combat revolver.
You hear a loud cracking sound coming from Alexander Oblomov!3
34+1 / 40 ROUNDS REMAINING
Alexander Oblomov is hit by the armor-piercing rifle bullet in the head!
31+1 / 40 ROUNDS REMAINING
Alexander Oblomov is hit by the armor-piercing rifle bullet in the chest!
Alexander Oblomov seizes up and falls limp, their eyes dead and lifeless…
You hear a loud cracking sound coming from Larry ‘FAT’ Westland!
The wound on Alexander Oblomov’s chest widens with a nasty ripping noise.
28+1 / 40 ROUNDS REMAINING
Unknown (as Alexander Oblomov)'s head flies off in an arc!

— Chat logs after both me and Plink were shot at —

— Bystander in the cell commenting on the MP loading their revolver —

Jonah Kalervo says, “HE IS LOADING.”
Jonah Kalervo says, “HIS REVOLVER.”

— In the chat logs below it shows that a marksman round was shot at us, this can be located to the inital breakout with no combat logs between us or MPs prior —

Svato Plink shakes John ‘JC’ Crimson trying to wake him up!
The marksman revolver bullet misses Svato Plink!
Jonah Kalervo says, “WOAH.”
Jonah Kalervo asks, “LETHALS?”
John ‘JC’ Crimson says, “SHOTS FIRED.”

— Conversations after the matter —

John ‘JC’ Crimson says, “I was merely seeking freedom and they started SHOOTING ME WITH LETHALS.”

John ‘JC’ Crimson says, “They shot at me with lethals dude.”
PFC Arianne ‘Vale’ Wehn says, “Damn”
PFC Arianne ‘Vale’ Wehn says, “Thats fucked up”

John ‘JC’ Crimson says, “They shot at me with lethals dude.”
PFC Arianne ‘Vale’ Wehn says, “Damn”
PFC Arianne ‘Vale’ Wehn says, “Thats fucked up”

John ‘JC’ Crimson says, “They shot at you too.”

3 Likes

(asked to delist not realising round had ended)

1 Like

even though it happened as part of a burst fire spray

shotguns do not have a burst fire mode

2 Likes

Please read the evidence provided, the decap happened during an mk2 burst fire spray, i have made it as consise as i can

1 Like

I cannot truly say if the decap was or was not intentional, but this is what I observed while ghosting
Crimson moving to PB in the head 1 MP named Casper, resulting in their death, but they were wearing a helmet, which possibly saved them from a decap. With the death of Casper the firefight effectively ended as all the MPs were dead.
Then Crimson moved towards the CMP, (who was already dead), lying on the floor, and PB them in the head. HOWEVER, the CMP was already DECAPED by that point as it happened earlier in the fight, which we know from as their body shows up as “Unknown (as Alexander Oblomov) showing they were already decapped.
I am sorry for any confusion that the earlier version of this witness account caused, but this detailed account now does support Crimson version of events as the decap happened during the firefight making it an incident

P.S edited to clarify some important details and corrected my version of events (important) as the decap happened earlier then originally suggested

5 Likes

again, the CMP was decapped prior during a fight while they were still alive in the evidence section, i had mistakenly thought they were still alive because they had a light source on their body (which ended up being a dropped gun) and truth be told i didnt realise i had head selected at the time

Here is a screenshot of chat regarding when they did face a decap

Im not certain if its very clear, however being decapped means that you cannot be decapped again, regardless of the fact that a securing shot to make sure a threat doesnt get back up, no action i could have done after the fact could make it any worse

3 Likes

logs support this

the logs in question

ATTACK: ///DEAD/// - MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with a buckshot shell from a �MK221 tactical shotgun in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull

ATTACK: ///DEAD/// - MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with an additional buckshot in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull

ATTACK: ///DEAD/// - MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with an additional buckshot in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull
ATTACK: ///DEAD/// - MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with an additional buckshot in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull

ATTACK: ///DEAD/// - MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with an armor-piercing rifle bullet from a �M41A pulse rifle MK2 (Wielded) in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull

ATTACK: ///DEAD/// - MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with an armor-piercing rifle bullet from a �M41A pulse rifle MK2 (Wielded) in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull

ATTACK: MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with an armor-piercing rifle bullet from a �M41A pulse rifle MK2 (Wielded) in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull

ATTACK: MisterMoon/(John ‘JC’ Crimson) shot Alexander Oblomov with an armor-piercing rifle bullet from a �M41A pulse rifle MK2 (Wielded) in the �Upper Deck Starboard-Bow Hull

he shoots the cmp, cmp dies, and then cmp is shot with buckshot

2 Likes

Hello. I was the Chief Military Police during the round. I tried to stay civil the whole time, but shit hit the fan pretty quick. I performed little to no arrests and did not set a single timer, but that was a second break in attempt into perma as far as I remember. I also only used force once, on a prisoner who picked up a rifle and started shooting people on brig.

First thing I see - one of the cells explodes (the other one already had a hole into maints in it), and I proceed into maintenance. Due to my crooked hands and a brilliant decision to equip a revolver (I started playing the original MGS 3 recently) I have basicly fired little to no shots as well. Next thing I know, I’m dead and decapped.

While I understand the nature of an accidental decapitation (there was no “fight” btw, I just dropped headless immediatly), I do not believe that the intentions were clear in the first place. Waging a mutiny over a non-issue does not stand well. I do not know what was the situation with the other MPs prior to that, and who shot who, but it was obvious to a naked eye that the situation was a shit-show, and should not have been continued in the first place. Instead it was decided that it must result in storming the brig with malice.

I believe that first and foremost a person must not search for an exuse to act maliciously, citing conversations with staff members, but ask to themselves if the situation calls for such radical action in the first place before acting.

Overall, I’m not that bothered by the incident, and would gladly forgive the bannestee (is that even a word?) should they understand their mistake instead of trying to employ sophistry.

3 Likes

There were no plans of a mutiny from what i was aware of, only the plans of freeing the captured, and as for being shot at, if not you then someone else had shot on sight without attempt of non lethal detainment, considering the previous firefight i had assumed that lethals had been authorised, as for the decap I am sorry that it happened to you, I believe i had switched to head earlier in the round for a different reason and didn’t notice, I did ask vending machine to heal you for what its worth

1 Like

Well, I think it’s okay then. The situation was clearly an accident (since I only wore a cap for protection), and the person in question did not intend to decap anyone. I talked to him a bit and do not have any problems on that front. As for the whole thing with storming the brig, etc - I was barely involved in the first place and do not know anything about it, so it’s for admins to decide.

2 Likes

For the record aswell, Stinvals did not give a shoot on sight order, it was a trigger happy MP that caused the confusion of the situation

2 Likes

Hello.

First of all, CM is a server with an average of around 100 players every day, most of them play Marine. While the vast majority of players do their best to follow the rules and enjoy the game, it is unacceptable for a small group to ruin an entire round simply because their friend was arrested for a minor crime. This is, above all, highly disrespectful to other players who are following the rules and it is especially disappointing to see such behavior from a former staff member who has repeatedly enforced and is expected to be familiar with these rules.

This incident began with John Crimson refusing deployment because his friend had been arrested for a minor crime. It escalated when Svato Plink, after his brig time ended, attempted to break his friend out by using explosives to breach Brig walls. This was followed by the participation of additional individuals, leading to MPs being killed, CMP being beheaded, and even a Doctor being prevented from reviving an MP. In every reviewed attack log, the initiating party for lethal escalation was again this group, except Caden Thomas.

Therefore, due to multiple violations of Rule 2 - Human Roleplay Standards, Rule 4 - Griefing, Permanent Removal, Rule 8 - Use Your Slot and Rule 10 - Escalation, Jailbreak, we are going to issue a week ban to the following players.

John JC Crimson
Caden Inept Thomas
Arianne Vale Wehn
Svato Plink

Additionally, a Fax Responder who should not have been involved in this incident has been removed from the Whitelist.