powerfulXtian - Commanding Officer Application

Commanding Officer Application - powerfulXtian

What is your BYOND key?

powerfulXtian

What is your Discord ID?

powerfulXtian

What is your timezone in UTC?

UTC-7

Player Name You Use Most?

Wayne Durstine

Ban Appeals, Whitelist and Staff Applications:

powerfulXtian - Commanding Officer Application | CO app; denied

Have you been banned in the last 3 months?

No.

If so, why?

X

Command Knowledge:

How familiar are you with command positions?

I consider myself to be extremely familiar with Command positions.

I am aware of the powers and limitations that come with playing XO or SL, primarily the former. The impact my presence that can effect the round, is immeasurable as any command position. Whether that would be deciding on appeals as a CMP, making quick reflex decisions as an SL, or ensuring each squad is performing to their maximum potential and capability, while also ensuring cohesiveness as an XO.

Hours in XO:

97.7

Hours in SL:

113.6

Character Information:

Why did your character decide to become the CO of a ship?

After the fall of the USS Vagabond, Captain Wayne Durstine was left jobless staying at a hotel next to an anchorpoint. During the disaster aboard the Vagabond, Wayne finally put together that perhaps, he shouldn’t be so clingy to Marine lives. He still feels a sense of duty to bring all of these Marines home, and a disapproval for the war, but understands his and all the Marine’s sacrifices save more lives than are killed during the wars and battles, especially with the terrorist group CLF strengthening his grip over the Neroid Sector. With his ship lost, he turns to the Almayer, after hearing they are looking for a Commanding Officer. With his family gone and nowhere to go, he decides to apply, a sense of duty still residing him. To potentially save more lives, and remember those who have and will eventually be forgotten.

How did your character attain the position of CO?

Durstine, with no family to go to, served the USCM faithfully. For nine years he had served the USS Vagabond, two as a Staff Officer, and the rest as a Captain of the ship. He had proven his skill and dedication through the years. After the loss of the USS Vagabond, Wayne was left jobless, and after two months sent an application to Divisional Command transfer to the CO position of the USS Almayer, which after careful consideration, was accepted.

Provide a short story of your CO.

Command Actions:

When do you believe it’s appropriate to pardon a prisoner?

Pardoning has a variety of applications during a round, however from what I both read in ML and observed from other COs, I believe it boils down to three reasons why I may pardon someone:

  1. Are they remorseful for their actions? Did they come to the brig kicking and screaming, or peacefully or apologetically?
  2. Are they likely to reoffend? Are they showing signs that when they get out, will do the exact same crime or any crime?
  3. Are they crucial/important to the operation? While it is a reason that is not as important as the others, ML does state Pardoning can be used if the CO believes it is in the best interest of the operation. Therefore, I believe it is a factor that should at least be considered.

By no means was this an exhaustive list and, I’m sure my time as CO there will be plenty of edgecases that come up, rather this list be the baseline that I use to judge suspects should I feel they be considered for a Pardon.

Give some examples of when you would or would not use pardon.

  1. I hear an explosion in Medbay, concerned I walk over there to see the chemistry walls damaged, an injured Doctor, and an MP cuffing them. I ask someone also observing the incident what happened as the MP takes them to the brig. The person explains that the Nurse was just in Chemistry when suddenly from their chem dispenser an explosion rang out, damaging the walls and spooking those nearby. I go to the brig, and check to confirm the story with the arresting officer, which the MP confirms is what happened, and tells me they are charged with damage to government property. The Doctor is peacefully sitting in their cell, as I go to ask them what happened, to of which the Doctor explains that they were mixing chemicals, when the chemical dispenser suddenly exploded, citing they may have accidentally created an explosive chemical. In this case, I WOULD pardon the Doctor, as they were remorseful and unlikely to reoffend seeing how it was a mere accident.

  2. I’ve just uncryoed, and command is greeting me. As I am walking to my CO quarters to equip myself properly, the SEA contacts me, asking if I can come to the brig. I oblige and head over there promptly. In there, I see a private rifleman in the cell, and the SEA standing with an MP. The SEA explains that the rifleman is new, and during briefing, had apparently shot another Marine, injuring them. They were promptly arrested by the MPs and taken to the brig, where they charged them with assault with a deadly weapon. The SEA explains that the rifleman didn’t even know he was being arrested, but nobody in command could do anything, as the charge technically is valid. In this case, I WOULD pardon the Rifleman, as they didn’t even know what they were doing, and with the SEA present to supervise them, are unlikely to reoffend.

  3. It is pre-drop, I am AFK in my quarters under the IC reason I had to file some paperwork, while in reality I had to take care of something outside the game. I had delegated briefing to my trustworthy Captain. Fast forward to when I return, I see the standard ARES message stating someone had been arrested, the Delta Specialist had been arrested for Assault, followed by the CMP asking for my presence in the brig to handle an appeal. I oblige and make my way to the brig, which I am greeted to the Delta Specialist exclaiming gratitude for my presence, citing to please pardon him so they can get to the Alamo in time for first drop. I ask the CMP what happened to of which they explain the Specialist had disrupted a portion of briefing, as they had started a fight with the Alpha Specialist. In this case, I WOULD NOT pardon the specialist. It is solely their fault that they acted up during briefing, and although they are useful to the operation, I would not risk myself to pardon a twitchy specialist. In addition to abusing their right to appeal to forcibly get an audience with me to ask with special treatment in the form of a pardon.

  4. It is briefing, a Private First Class Rifleman throws a throwing knife at the MP, when sternly told to stop, he throws another knife at the at the MP. To of which he is promptly arrested for assault. During his arrest, he questions what the MP is doing, almost acting as if he were a new player, his loadout consisting of weapons with attachments, MREs, generally a loadout seen in more experienced Marines. Over comms, he makes messages to his squad asking why he is being carried away by an MP, and why he can’t move. When I visit him in the brig after briefing to ask why they were doing that, he speaks in broken English, saying messages how he is “new” and has no idea what he’s doing. In this case, I WOULD NOT pardon this rifleman, in my eyes, they are clearly trying to act new in order to cause disruption and grief. Now, they are trying to get away with it to potentially cause more havoc by getting a pardon from me.

When do you believe it’s appropriate to use a Battlefield Execution?

Battlefield Executions as iconic as they are, are not a privilege to be taken lightly. I would only use them in situations where the situation has gone completely out of hand and control needs to be asserted immediately. Or, someone is hindering my ability to command through their actions, and MPs are not available to assist.

Give some examples of when you would or would not use Battlefield Execution.

  1. It is briefing and I have allowed the Captain to conduct briefing, when a Delta Rifleman picks a fight with an Alpha Rifleman, however the Delta Rifleman over-escalates, immediately pulling out their rifle and firing on the Alpha Rifleman, killing them on the spot. The Alpha Rifleman’s buddies unbuckle from their seats, ready to retaliate. With no MPs in sight, I immediately move to and EXECUTE the Delta Rifleman. Without MP assistance and an impending brawl that will cost more lives, I had to quickly end the situation before it grew out of control.

  2. It is the middle of an FOB siege, there is a fierce battle between the Marines and Xenomorphs, I had deployed groundside to assist the fighting. The Bravo SL comes up to me and tells me we should evac, as we are clearly gaining nothing from the FOB siege but losing more lives. I reject his offer, and order them to keep defending. The SL does not follow orders however, drawing his weapon and telling me that they heavily suggest we should evac. I notice his gun out, and ask him if that is a threat. The SL dodges the question and once again requests me to evac. I give him a stern warning that if he does not put his gun away and keep holding the siege, there will be deep consequences. They do not follow my order, and again this time wielding his weapon, tells me we are to evac. With multiple warnings given and his refusal to follow my orders, I battlefield execute the SL. They had multiple chances to back down but did not comply, with their gun in hand pointed at me, I was credibly being threatened that if I did not evac, I would be killed. Even if he had not outright told me, his actions told me he was about to execute me.

  3. The Marines are pushing after an OB clears, I am overwatching one of the Marines as they throw a CAS flare. A few moments later, I see the CAS do a firemission on the Marine push, killing few and injuring multiple. I am forced to call a full retreat back into the nearest cadeline, as we no longer have the numbers to push and need to preserve those who have been lost. The GP remains silent over comms. As everyone in the squad channels are calling for a BE, I decide to not battlefield execute the GP. Although circumstances a bit questionable, it appears to have been an accident by the GP. Depending on the circumstances, I can also turn to MPs to punish the GP, rather than just round removing them.

  4. It is pre-drop, everyone is boarded on the Alamo, I am there to see the Marines off, when suddenly, the SADAR specialist fires a rocket towards the DCC, exploding them and taking multiple Marines in the crossfire. Immediately, other Marines point to the specialist, some shoving and stripping them. I delay the drop to allow medics to revive the dead, pulling the SADAR out. An SL uses their ziptie cuffs to cuff the SADAR as I ask them why they did that. They claimed they accidentally fired their rocket launcher, after jokingly pointing it at the DCC, in this case I would not battlefield execute them, as they are already safely restrained and appear remorseful for their actions, instead I would delegate to an MP, to have them charged for Manslaughter.

3 Likes

Playtimes listed above ^

I also want to make a note here - currently on fall break for the next week or so. After that, I may not be able to get on CM as often as currently. I will try to make time for it for the duration of this application but, life is life.

1 Like

This guy is pretty good. I’m confident in his commanding abilities, and think he’ll be a good choice for the WL. +1

2 Likes

Wayne is a solid command player. Hell a very solid player in general and has the skills needed to be a CO. He gets my +1!

4 Likes

good XO, good CMP, great SL; not much else to add that wasnt done on this app or the prior to emphasize how good xtian is. +1

3 Likes

Overall Good Player

+1

3 Likes

Very solid individual and player. Definitely worthy of the WL +1

3 Likes

Wayne’s good people. I’m always happy to see him in command. He’s responsive and makes sound decisions. +1, would follow him to my death.

3 Likes

+1 a bright star amongst the recent XOs line-up.

2 Likes

Hey Wayne, your app answers are fine and dandy so I’m not going to comment on that here. What I am going to comment on is your in character behavior and your command ability.

To be frank, I feel like you’ve slid backwards on this app. In observing you I’ve seen a general lack of consistency that’s made me considerably less confident in your ability to uphold the standards that we expect a CO to be held to. This is to say that you’ve been extremely hit or miss in every round that I’ve observed, with minimal inbetween. I cannot for the life of me get a solid bead on your command abilities.

I also have a good amount of concern regarding your willingness and ability to RP, having seen it be most common for you to only interact with people when you need something of them or they have done something that demands your attention. Whitelisted roles, and CO especially, are meant to uplift the standard for roleplay on the server. When you speed through brief and ignore marines trying to have a conversation with you, you’re not behaving as would be expected of a CO. We’re not expecting you to deliver a Lauffer speech nor to hold a boxing tournament to determine who gets FOB duty, but we do expect you to not close yourself off to RP opportunities.

As it currently stands, I don’t think you’re ready for the CO WL. I’d urge you to focus on your schooling, take some time off and come back at CM with a fresh mind.

For now, -1.

6 Likes

Heya.

First I’d like to start off by saying thank you for the feedback. It helps to have a councillors input since my last application.

When my last application was denied, I was given the advice:
“That being said: there are noted issues with your presence in CIC (frequently leaving it, for example), having trouble with communications/announcements, and having issues with tunnel visioning and focusing on narrow aspects instead of the big picture” by the senator, Naut.

Therefore, I am actively trying to improve myself in that regard, staying in CIC more, being watchful of the comms I see throughout the operation, and being more active with announcements, with in my opinion success to that.

It would help a lot to give me an idea of where exactly the areas of consistency you are looking for. Do I need to announce more? Do I need to start enforcing my command more? Less? I am very open to advice, but I cannot improve what I am not told to improve on.

That said, to my defense. I agree on the fact that my rounds have been hit or miss, but honestly? Sometimes rounds just don’t work out. And that’s okay with me, because I enjoy commanding the round, and I enjoy when Marines don’t complain about command, and I infer that I did good during that round.

As for what you have mentioned with RP:

I assume you are specifically meaning XO when you say this. Correct me if I am wrong.

Looking back personally at my previous rounds, I see truth in that I only interact with others when I need something. However, to my memory I do not remember to my knowledge of actively ignoring those trying to strike up a conversation with me. I always have my name, and Executive Officer related phrases and acronyms highlighted in the chat.

However, I will take this account and try to RP more during my rounds. Thank you for your feedback.

1 Like

I’ve got to agree with Mike, and I think I said as much a week or so ago after observing one of your rounds.

It seems you’ve gone backwards in your XO’ing. Nobody is expecting nor cares about win/loss or anything like that, we all know things don’t work out, but it seems like you’re almost wildly inconsistent in how you play XO and if you’re on top of things and actively commanding or just reacting.

Then there’s the RP side of things. While it mostly focuses on XO, I’ve also seen you be involved in some questionable incidents when you’re playing as an officer that’s not the XO. This has ranged to seemingly baiting marines as the CMP into arrests, to fighting a PFC as an IO because he beat you to the req line.

Overall, I’m disappointed because I really thought you were close on your last app, but I can’t support this one. -1

2 Likes

Good afternoon all.

As this application enters the mark of just a week before the month of this application being up is hit. I believe the good and the bad of myself as an applicant has been shown here.

As some have may described - I’m a good applicant for CO, command well, handle situations well, etc. But others, mainly Harry and Campin have described glaring issues in my consistency both in CIC and RP. More of an emphasis on the RP side of things. And I’m sure there are others who share similar feelings to my performance in rounds up to today, to of which I personally invite you to post it here if it is genuinely something I can improve on. I’m okay with my application forum becoming a place of criticism so long as it’s constructive. Every piece of feedback helps, and as I always say - I cannot improve what I do not know I am doing wrong.

My playstyle for the past three weeks, have been, I recognize, hit or miss. I’m not going to say all the days I have missed were just bad days. This is my fault, and will always be.

I have considered even withdrawing my application at times, mainly now but all throughout this application and my previous one. I’ve had doubts within myself. But, I do want to become a CO. I do genuinely want to become apart of the CO community and it’s whitelist, and therefore I will not be withdrawing this application.

From now until the CO Council decides to vote, I promise to clean up my act and do better. I recognize what I have done in the past, at times was unbecoming of someone who wants to be apart of the whitelist.

If you all can give me, one more chance during this time, I can prove to you all I am ready.

3 Likes

Hello, Wayne.

The council has voted, and unfortunately, at this time, we are opting to deny this application to the CO whitelist. You came so close to meeting the standards; this was a tough internal discussion. You have a lot of good qualities, but as you admitted in a DM to our senator, you have your faults.

You may reapply again on November 29th. I am aware of the DM you sent to the senator, and I am proud of you for recognizing where you were strong and where you had faults. In the last week, I’ve noticed you are taking great strides to improve your general attitude toward many things, and you can keep growing and improving. You’ll stand a good chance of getting in.

Don’t get too discouraged, man. Some of us are rooting for you pretty hard. Keep on the grind, and if you need help or mentoring, a few of us (myself included) are fine with you reaching out anytime.

9 Likes

Added co:denied and removed co:waiting